October 21, 2025

The Phenomenon of Imposter Syndrome

Explore the phenomenon of imposter syndrome, its mental health links, and evidence-based ways to overcome self-doubt.

Estimated Read Time
3
minutes.

The Phenomenon of Imposter Syndrome

Introduction

The term imposter syndrome (also known as the impostor phenomenon) refers to the pervasive experience of doubting one’s achievements, attributing success to external factors (such as luck) and living with a persistent fear of being exposed as a fraud, despite evidence of competence.
In this article, we explore the phenomenon of imposter syndrome in depth, examine how it intersects with mental-health conditions including depression, anxiety, ADHD, OCD, borderline personality disorder (BPD), psychosis, eating disorders and more, and highlight practical strategies for clinicians and clients in a mental-health setting.

What is Imposter Syndrome?

The phenomenon of imposter syndrome was first described by Pauline R. Clance and Suzanne A. Imes in 1978. Though not classified as a formal psychiatric disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) or the International Classification of Diseases (ICD), it is widely recognized in academic and clinical literature as a psychological pattern with significant associations to mental-health outcomes.

Characteristics include:

  • Persistent self-doubt about one’s accomplishments

  • Attributing success to external factors (luck, timing, help) rather than internal capability

  • Fear of being “found out” or exposed as inadequate

  • Discounting compliments or external validation

  • Over-preparation, perfectionism, self-handicapping behaviours
    For example, a narrative review shows prevalence ranging from 9 % to 82 % depending on measurement tool and context.

Why does it matter?

Though the term may feel colloquial, it has real implications for mental health and professional functioning. Research among medical students found strong associations between imposter phenomenon and both depression (PR = 1.53) and anxiety (PR = 1.317) in one sample.

In work-settings, individuals with imposter syndrome report lower job satisfaction, higher burnout, less organisational citizenship behaviour. Thus, for a clinic like ours in the mental-health space, recognising and addressing the phenomenon is essential — especially when patients present with underlying pathologies.

How Imposter Syndrome Intersects With Other Mental Health Conditions

Depression & Anxiety

The relationship between imposter syndrome and mood or anxiety disorders is robust. Studies indicate that the self-critical, fraudulent-feeling mindset contributes to depressive and anxious symptomology.
From a clinical perspective, when a person presents with depression or anxiety, it is prudent to assess whether they are also struggling with imposter feelings — as this can serve as a perpetuating factor in self-esteem, rumination, avoidance, and inhibition of help-seeking.

ADHD

While direct research on imposter syndrome in ADHD is more limited, the mechanisms overlap: ADHD may lead to inconsistent performance, missed deadlines, or executive-function struggles, which can trigger beliefs of being “less than” peers and heighten imposter feelings. A clinician should explore whether the patient attributes performance gaps to personal incompetence rather than neuro-cognitive variation or organisational factors.

OCD (Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder)

The perfectionism and over-checking common in OCD can dovetail with imposter syndrome’s perfectionist subtype (those who feel they must never make mistakes). For example, the “perfectionist imposter” feels that unless something is flawless they are a fraud. This intersection may increase risk of rumination, avoidance of tasks unless “perfect” and exacerbate OCD cycles.

BPD (Borderline Personality Disorder)

Individuals with BPD often struggle with identity-instability, feelings of emptiness and self-worth issues. When combined with imposter syndrome, they may feel not only like a fraud externally, but also internally disconnected from a consistent self-identity. Clinically, this may manifest as alternating between over-compensating and self-devaluation, and may require integrated treatment strategies.

Psychosis / Schizophrenia-Spectrum

The link here is less direct, but still relevant: for individuals in early-phase psychosis or established schizophrenia, self-doubt, stigma, and internalized shame can fuel a belief of being fraudulent or undeserving of support or recovery. Addressing imposter-type cognitions may improve engagement, help-seeking, and adherence.

Eating Disorders

Eating disorders often involve perfectionism, black-and-white thinking (“If I’m not perfect, I’m worthless”), shame, and high self-criticism. Those same beliefs can underpin imposter syndrome: “I only succeeded because I represented the perfect body/image; if that falters, I am a fraud.” Integrative treatment can benefit from recognizing this overlap.

Types and Subtypes of Imposter Syndrome

According to research, there are five commonly described sub-types of imposter syndrome: 

  1. The Perfectionist — Everything must be perfect; one flaw equals failure.

  2. The Expert — They believe they must know everything before starting; if they don’t know something, they feel fraud.

  3. The Natural Genius — They measure competence by ease and speed; if it’s hard or slow, they feel inadequate.

  4. The Soloist — They believe they must do things alone; asking for help is a sign they are a fraud.

  5. The Superhero — They push to excel in multiple roles (parent, partner, professional, volunteer); struggle in any role equals exposure.
    For clinicians, recognizing the subtype can help tailor interventions, e.g., Counteracting “soloist” beliefs by encouraging help-seeking and reframing help as strength.

Clinical Implications and Treatment Considerations

Assessment

  • Ask about internal beliefs: “Do you feel at times you’ve ‘fooled’ others into thinking you’re more capable than you feel you are?”

  • Use validated scales such as the Clance Impostor Phenomenon Scale (CIPS) though note that imposter syndrome is not a formal diagnosis.

  • Explore comorbid mental-health conditions: mood/anxiety disorders, ADHD, OCD, eating disorders, BPD, psychosis spectrum.

Therapeutic Strategies

  1. Cognitive-Behavioural Interventions: Challenge the belief “I’m a fraud” with objective evidence of competence (e.g., past wins, feedback).

  2. Psychoeducation: Help the client understand imposter syndrome is common and not a sign of personal deficit.

  3. Scaling and Reframing Success: Encourage clients to keep “evidence of competence” logs, reflect on their achievements and attribute them to internal as well as external factors.

  4. Mindfulness and Self-Compassion: Since imposter feelings are often driven by harsh self-critical voices, interventions aimed at self-compassion can buffer internalised shame.

  5. Peer Support and Mentoring: Encouraging discussion of imposter feelings in supportive communities can normalise the experience and reduce isolation.

  6. Organisational/Cultural Change: In workplace or academic settings, acknowledging the phenomenon at group level, providing mentoring, normalising help-seeking, and establishing cultures of psychological safety can reduce imposter experiences.

Integration with Other Conditions

For conditions like ADHD, OCD, BPD, psychosis or eating disorders, the treatment of imposter syndrome does not stand alone — rather it is integrated:

  • In ADHD: work on executive-function supports plus belief-restructuring about competence.

  • In OCD: address perfection-ism, all-or-nothing thinking and self-monitoring linked to imposter subtype.

  • In BPD: integrate self-worth and identity work with imposter cognitions (e.g., “If I’m not perfect, I don’t belong”).

  • In psychosis/schizophrenia: incorporate psychoeducation about imposter feelings into relapse prevention, stigma reduction and self-belief rebuilding.

  • In eating disorders: reframe the internal narrative that equates worth-and-success with body/image, incorporate imposter-related beliefs into cognitive work around identity and achievement.

Why Integrative Care Matters

Given the overlapping psychological, neurocognitive and social dimensions, an integrative approach is key. At clinics like ours, being located in Chelsea, NYC, we emphasise multidisciplinary perspectives: psychiatry, psychotherapy, nutritional work, executive-function coaching, trauma-informed care, group support. In doing so, we can address imposter syndrome in the context of broader mental-health conditions and life-circumstances rather than silo it as a “self-help” issue.
In addition, from a marketing & SEO standpoint, creating content about “imposter syndrome + ADHD,” “imposter syndrome in anxiety/depression,” or “therapy for imposter syndrome NYC” helps attract the target audience of high-achieving professionals in metropolitan contexts who may silently carry these beliefs while coping with comorbid conditions.

Practical Tips for Individuals

  • Keep a “success file”: record feedback, completed tasks, positive outcomes → when you feel like a fraud you can revisit objective evidence of competence.

  • Reframe perfectionism: Accept that high standards are fine but unrelenting “must never fail” is linked to imposter syndrome.

  • Normalise help-seeking: Asking for help doesn’t mean you’re a fraud — it may mean you are a high performer recognising complexity.

  • Use peer sharing: Talk with trusted colleagues/friends about your doubts; odds are they feel similarly.

  • Celebrate progress, not just output: Many impostor-types discount wins. Practice naming small wins.

  • Mind your language: Instead of “I must always succeed,” shift toward “I’m competent and growing” — this subtle shift reduces internalised fraud beliefs.

  • If you present with mood/anxiety/ADHD/OCD etc., ask your provider about whether imposter beliefs might be part of the clinical picture.

Conclusion

The phenomenon of imposter syndrome is widespread, particularly amongst high-achieving professionals and students, but it remains under-recognized in many clinical settings. Because it often co-occurs with depression, anxiety, ADHD, OCD, eating disorders, BPD and even psychosis-spectrum challenges, it merits attention from integrative mental-health providers. By understanding the cognitive-behavioral underpinnings, recognizing sub-types, integrating with comorbid conditions, and deploying evidence-based strategies, clinicians and clients can jointly dismantle fraudulent-self beliefs, reinforce internalized competence, and unlock fuller growth and well-being.

About Integrative Psych in Chelsea, NYC

Integrative Psych is a leading practice in Chelsea, Manhattan, committed to providing integrative, evidence-informed treatment for complex mental-health conditions in adults and emerging adults. Our team of psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, neuropsychologists, executive-function coaches and mindfulness practitioners collaborates to create personalized care plans — because we know mental health is multi-dimensional. If you or someone you know has ever felt like they’re “not good enough,” “faking it,” or “exposed” despite outward success, we welcome you to explore our specialty in perfectionism, imposter syndrome, ADHD, anxiety, mood disorders and beyond. Visit us at Integrative Psych.org or reach out to schedule a consultation in our Chelsea office — together we turn self-doubt into self-mastery.

Meet Your Team of Experts

Have ADHD?

Take Our Quiz

Have Anxiety?

Take Our Quiz

Have Depression?

Take Our Quiz

We're now accepting new patients

Book Your Consultation
Integrative Psych therapy office with a chair, sofa, table, lamp, white walls, books, and a window

Other Psych Resources